This is kinda like having the same hair brush for life. Like, we get it and props for trying to cut down on trash but hygiene stuff I’m alright with tossing out eventually.

I don’t know man. Seems like you’re in search of a unicorn. Lasting a long time and comfy out of the box are not traits that typically coincide.

Probably the model you selected. Ohana’s feel pretty good out of the box but I have low arches so eventually the arch support compresses and then they’re perfect. All shoes break in to some extent.

I just bought my 3rd pair of Ohana’s this fall in at least a decade. They last way longer than everything else that looks decent. I used to get 6-9 months out of Rainbows. My Olukai Ohana’s last 2 years minimum. Skip Olukai’s leather models. They’re more fashion than reliability.

They do break in over time. I bought one pair of Reef sandals. Never again.

Bass Pro/Cabela’s is a crapshoot if you’re looking for quality. They charge MSRP for non-Bass Pro brands while selling bottom tier trash at prices you’d pay for the other quality brands online. Then when the season is over they mark them down to prices that make sense for junk like a corporate garage sale but they only have things from China.