Also sidenote, my hunter boots have never leaked, they are completely waterproof! But they also don't keep my feet warm. I can wear them in the rain but not on a snowy day

How do these compare to hunter boots?

I have a pair of hunters that I've had since 2016. I think I'll be able to get a few more yrs out of them, but there are a few small cracks in the rubber in some areas. I like the look of these, would consider getting them as a replacement if they are known to hold up well