One has David Harbour who is pretty universally liked , the other has Mel Gibson who is a pretty well known Anti-Semite.

Disclaimer..I have seen Violent Night - pretty good , nothing special. The fight scenes were awesome. I have not seen Fatman due to the above reasoning

Personally it’s The Prestige (hot take I know) but it’s my favorite movie, and there’s not a weak spot in the movie. So a little bias but definitely at least a 9

10 is the Perfect movie ( I’ve never given a 5, because then a movie can never be better)

9.9-9.0 is an almost perfect movie , masterpiece

8.9-8.0 is a great movie

7.9-7 is a good movie

6.9-6.0 is ok - nothing special but worth a watch

5.9 and below is bad - 4’s are terrible and so forth