Avhumboldt-pup0902
Avhumboldt-pup0902 t1_jaup49r wrote
Reply to comment by Hinoto-no-Ryuji in Banning Words Won’t Make the World More Just - The Atlantic by vaikrunta
Yea, it's been a very long time since I've last re-read them. The slam poem "an angry letter to JK Rowling from Cho Chang" is my primary source for the critique. Which, maybe in Harry Potter is passable but looking at it from the perspective of western writers writing Asian characters is a bit different.
I also think in the grand scheme of her digging her heels into transphobia and aligning herself with right-wingers to that end, who generally are very racist, it's hard to uncouple.
But I agree, it's certainly good food for thought!
Avhumboldt-pup0902 t1_jaudhx2 wrote
Reply to comment by Hinoto-no-Ryuji in Banning Words Won’t Make the World More Just - The Atlantic by vaikrunta
Other people have written on Cho playing into the stereotype of the tragic and sad Asian girl who loses, through death or other circumstances, her white love interest (Miss Saigon, Madame Butterfly). So there is that to contend with as far as her actual character.
Avhumboldt-pup0902 t1_jegmbyo wrote
Reply to Stoner by John Williams blew me away by BroncoAccountant
If your wife reads it, what book will you read in return?